Enjoy country-style rooms, tennis, pool, and upscale dining at The Pridwin Hotel & Cottages on Shelter Island’s scenic Shore Rd. Rated 4.3 with 276 reviews.
Relaxed seaside accommodations with a historic charm, appreciated for peaceful surroundings and access to local dining and outdoor activities.
GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.
Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.
Rooms, shared spaces, dining and exterior — grouped so you can skim quickly.
Situated on a 10-acre property by Crescent Beach, The Pridwin Hotel & Cottages offers a relaxed seaside setting with a blend of country-style rooms and cottages. The hotel combines the charm of a historic 1927 building with resort-like facilities, including an outdoor pool, tennis courts, a fitness center, and a spa. Guests can enjoy air-conditioned accommodations with access to free Wi-Fi and a pet-friendly environment, making it suitable for a range of travelers.
The property features upscale dining options such as The Terrace at The Pridwin, a restaurant that has received positive feedback with an average rating of 4.3 from recent visitors. Many guests appreciate the availability of room service, a bar, and a kid-friendly atmosphere, while noting the absence of an airport shuttle. Practical amenities like free parking, laundry service, and beach access contribute to a comfortable stay.
Located 2 miles from the Shelter Island North Ferry terminal and about 4 miles from Gardiner's Bay Country Club, the hotel is well positioned for visitors looking to explore the island or enjoy nearby outdoor activities. The property’s 4.3 rating, backed by 276 reviews, reflects generally favorable opinions, though the overall guest score of 3.4 suggests some mixed experiences. This balance may appeal to travelers seeking a quieter, traditional seaside retreat rather than a highly modern resort.
Nearby accommodations with strong reviews include Shelter Island House and The Harbor Front Inn, providing alternatives within a short drive. Check-in is from 4 PM, with check-out by 11 AM, allowing guests ample time to unwind in this peaceful and accessible destination.
The short version: what's available day-to-day, and the key practical details most travelers search for.
On a 10-acre property by Crescent Beach, this relaxed hotel dates to 1927. It's 2 miles from the Shelter Island North Ferry terminal and 4 miles from Gardiner's Bay Country Club.
Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.
Stay at Rio Gran Motel in Detroit, offering free WiFi and parking. Close to top attractions like Detroit Institute of Arts and Mo...
Contemporary hotel in Cornelius, NC with free WiFi, breakfast, parking, outdoor pool, gym, and petfriendly rooms. Near Davidson ...
Stay at Wyndham Garden McAllen At La Plaza Mall with indoor/outdoor pool, free WiFi, breakfast, and airport shuttle, minutes from...
Stay at Courtyard by Marriott Providence Downtown with free WiFi, an exercise room, and a casual American restaurant near Rhode Is...
Stay at Deer Run Motor Inn in Jeffersonville, VT. Enjoy free WiFi, free parking, and easy access to Stowe Mountain Resort and loc...
Stay at Fairfield by Marriott Inn & Suites Charlottesville North, a 4.1rated hotel offering outdoor pool, free breakfast, and eas...
Stay at Tropical Villas of Venice Beach, a 4.9rated motel with free WiFi, outdoor pool, and kitchen in rooms, just a 10minute w...
Discover The Kimberly Hotel in New York with rooftop bar, dining, free WiFi, and easy access to landmarks like Empire State Build...
Enjoy entertainment, a casino, 8 dining options, and a river beach at Harrah's Laughlin. Conveniently located near Colorado River ...
Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.
